Compare a proposed payment recovery process with the recovery you already achieve, then subtract the fees and monthly costs.
Use your figures: Open the calculator. All amounts in the examples are illustrative and can be read in one currency of your choice.
Compare the same group of failed invoices
A recovery report can look encouraging while giving you little evidence about improvement. Some failed invoices would have been paid through existing retries or customer follow-up. The useful business question is how much more a proposed process might recover from the same failed-payment population.
Choose a defined invoice set of records and a fixed recovery window. Decide whether your rate is based on invoice count or monetary value. For a revenue calculation, a value-based rate is the direct fit. Do not combine a count-based failure rate with average revenue without checking whether invoice sizes differ.
Calculate additional recovery, not total recovery
Annual failed value = monthly billings × 12 × initial failure percentage. Additional recovery = annual failed value × (target recovery − current recovery). Write the recovery rates as fractions for this calculation. A rise from 40% to 65% is a 25-percentage-point improvement.
The calculator charges the entered fee on positive additional recovered value, then subtracts the additional annual fixed cost. If your contract charges on all recovered value, calculate that fee arrangement separately. Do not treat the tool’s fee basis as the provider’s contract.
A fee-inclusive example
Monthly billings of 100,000 at an 8% initial failure rate give 96,000 annual failed value. Moving recovery from 40% to 65% adds 24,000. A 5% fee on that additional value is 1,200. Fixed cost of 150 a month adds 1,800, leaving 21,000 in net annual improvement.
Find the break-even recovery improvement
When failed value is positive and the fee is below 100%, the required recovery improvement is annual fixed cost ÷ (annual failed value × (1 − fee fraction)). Here that is 1,800 ÷ (96,000 × 0.95) = 1.97 percentage points, giving a target recovery of about 41.97% from the 40% baseline.
This holds the entered fee basis and costs constant. If the required target exceeds 100%, recovery alone cannot break even under those assumptions. Recovered cash is still not profit; fulfillment costs and other business expenses are outside this comparison.
Check what the improvement really means
Separate recoverable payment problems from cancelled subscriptions and invalid accounts. Do not assume recovering one invoice guarantees every future renewal. Compare invoice status and cash received after the same observation window. Stripe’s revenue recovery documentation describes recovery features; our example is a constructed comparison, not a promised provider outcome.
If the invoice was never issued, begin with completed-work billing reconciliation. That is an earlier stage of the revenue process.
Use a lower recovery case
With 96,000 annual failed value, moving recovery from 40% to 50% adds 9,600. A 5% fee on that additional value is 480; 1,800 annual fixed cost leaves 7,320. Compare that case with the 21,000 target case and confirm the fee basis in the provider agreement. Total recovered cash and additional recovered cash are different figures.
- Measure failed payment value for one defined period.
- Compare current and target recovery on the same basis.
- Calculate only the additional recovered value.
- Subtract its fee and additional fixed recovery cost.
Source and further reading
- Stripe recovery analytics documentation. Check the provider’s report definitions before comparing failed and recovered payment value.
Related reading
Work through your own numbers
Use the failed payment recovery roi calculator to test a baseline and a cautious improvement. Check the calculation guide if you need help with currencies, sharing or assumptions.
Prepared and reviewed by the ProWorkstack editorial team. Examples are constructed calculations, not customer results. See our editorial standards.